January 1, Assassin Cases Expose Legal Loopholes

Wyatt’s Take

• Prosecutors struggled to get the toughest punishment in two high-profile murder cases with political motives.
• State laws don’t offer clear death penalty options unless the victim fits strict protected categories.
• This reveals a big gap in how political violence is handled by our justice system.

Two recent murder cases—one involving UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, the other political commentator Charlie Kirk—have sparked debate over how America handles politically motivated killings.

Prosecutors allege Luigi Mangione shot Thompson and left political messages at the scene, while Tyler Robinson stands accused of killing Kirk and copying the pattern.

Both victims were fathers with families, and both crimes appear political, but neither state could seek the death penalty easily due to legal technicalities.

New York’s terrorism charge against Mangione was tossed by the judge, so he faces life with parole still possible.

Utah, with no terrorism statute, charged Robinson with aggravated murder but faces tough challenges because only one shot was fired.

“Interestingly, had [Robinson] been charged in federal court, it would’ve been a terrorist act,” said Greg Rogers, a Utah Valley University professor and former FBI agent.

He pointed to Mangione’s journals allegedly explaining his motives, and noted that some supporters have even rallied in costume outside court.

“How did we get to where tens of thousands of our citizens think this is great?” he asked.

Experts say that just planning a murder isn’t enough for the death penalty anymore. Cases need aggravating factors—like targeting a cop, politician, or child.

Matt Mangino, a former DA, said, “There has to be something more.”

Businessmen or commentators like Thompson and Kirk rarely fit the law’s requirements for the harshest punishment, even if politics played a role.

Without clearer statutes, prosecutors risk losing on technicalities or seeing their charges reversed on appeal.

Get news that matters to America’s backbone. Sign up for more stories grounded in common sense.

Wyatt Matters

When laws can’t keep up with rising political violence, regular folks pay the price. Our system should protect every American, no matter who they are, or what they believe in.

Read the full story